Committing to a decision between two seemingly appealing options is difficult.
Each day, we are faced with a multitude of choices, products, and decisions that affect both ourselves and the world around us. This section explores the many available choices we make each day and how they relate to a minimalist lifestyle.
Once a week, I will compare two seemingly attractive options against each other and determine what’s more favorable for building and maintaining a minimalist lifestyle.
Electronic Reading Device vs. Traditional Books
Today, people who consider reading an essential practice are facing an increasing amount of options.
The advent of the electronic reading devices (ERDs) are attractive options for many people who enjoy reading — especially minimalists. ERDs contain specific attributes that are conducive for living a minimalist lifestyle.
In particular, Generation Y minimalists are drawn towards ERDs because they’ve always lived in the technological and computer-based era. Generation Y members embrace new technology and generally flock towards discovering ways to utilize new technological products.
Benefits and flaws are embedded in ERDs and traditional books. These differences can significantly influence people following a minimalist lifestyle. Specifically, Generation Y is experiencing the painful economic reality of The Great Recession. Choosing a suitable reading application contains the potential to assist as an aid on a minimalist path or act as a deterrent. The following focuses on the major pros and cons of each option, with regards to a minimalist perspective.

Electronic Reading Device Pros
Create Space: Book collections can be stored in one tiny ERD, drastically creating physical space. I’ve experienced a surprise at how much room is necessary to store books. The issue of more space presents a personal mission for many minimalists. ERDs provide a unique ability to add and store new books within one platform. Apple’s iPad, Amazon’s Kindle, and Barnes & Noble’s Nook are current popular ERDs that each takes up a minimal amount of space. For example, the iPad contains a 10-inch screen while the Kindle’s screen rests at 6-inches. (There is also a 9.7-inch Kindle model) These ERDs offer an alternative towards using precious space to store your book collection.
Pocket Bookstore: Your book collection can fit into your pocket thanks to ERDs. ERDs are capable of downloading books, magazines, and PDF’s without being connected to a personal computer. Minimalists living location-independent lifestyles are offered flexibility to read. Instead of making the nerve-wracking decision to bring along your favorite two books when leaving the house, ERDs let you take your entire book collection.
- Kindle 10 ounces
- Nook 11.6 ounces / 12.1 ounces (Depending on version)
- iPad 24 ounces
Save Paper: Paper wasting is eliminated with ERDs. Making a commitment to live sustainable lifestyles is an appealing factor that draws many to minimalism. Much of the average American’s 4.39 pounds of daily produced trash originates from paper related products. Using an ERD conserves trees and paper that indirectly helps to heal the Earth.

Electronic Reading Device Cons
Cost (Relative to Books): Purchasing an ERD can be expensive. Traditional books are much cheaper because they don’t require a separate device.
- The Nook- $149 (Wi-Fi only version) or $199
- Kindle – $189 $139
- iPad – $499 – $700. (Additional $130 for 3G service).
Lack of Sharing: ERD users don’t control the property of their purchase. Digital rights management means loaning your e-purchased books to family and friends is illegal.
Battery Issues: Battery life and eco-friendly issues plague ERDs. It’s necessary to monitor the ERD’s battery life. While many ERDs have relatively long battery life, periodically monitoring the battery remains. Not having access to a charger (on holiday, broken battery, etc.) can bring frustration and stress. Also, ERDs aren’t biodegradable. Disposing an ERD might harm the environment — an act that contrasts simple living ideals.
Availability: Not all ERD bookstores are created equal. Certain books and files aren’t available for purchase or browsing depending upon the specific ERD. For example, Nook users are limited to Barnes & Noble’s electronic book directory. Kindle and iPad users each are contained to their respective book libraries as well. If the book you want isn’t listed in the right directory, you might be out of luck.

Traditional Book Pros
Familiarity: Traditional books are simply charming. Holding a traditional book offers comfort to many people. The familiarity of weight, texture and printing material just feels right. The Kindle replicates the aesthetic reading style of traditional books with e-ink, but there is nothing like the real thing.
Sense of Community: Traditional books and bookstores are inherently linked. Bookstores provide communities of like-minded people reading and interacting with each other. Bookstores are more likely to stay in business if people continue browsing and buying traditional books. Bookstore browsing gives minimalists a free activity that’s fun and entertaining. Also, traditional books can legally be loaned and shared between friends. Essentially, the intellectual property rests with the traditional book purchaser, helping minimalists re-use books and donate used books to others.
Durability: Traditional books can take a beating. Pen marks, coffee stains, and drops aren’t going to significantly damage traditional books to the point of unreadability. Alternatively, each one of these can severely damage an ERD. This feature alone can save minimalists money over time because replacing a book due to damage rarely occurs compared to ERDs.

Traditional Books Cons
Wasting Paper: Unfortunately, traditional books consume a great source of paper. A minimalist lifestyle supports eco-friendly practices. Traditional books often aren’t recycled, and as a result, paper is wasted.
Clutter Monsters: Traditional books often accumulate space over time. The addition of books can sneak up on minimalists until potentially, stacks of books replace open space. This unsettling dynamic creates clutter in the lives of minimalists – establishing a physical barrier to clarity. Clarity acts an element to enhance personal development. Many simple-living enthusiasts actively fight clutter.
Location Attachment: Traditional book lovers must often choose between their favorite books. Traveling, getting out of the house, or even daily work commutes are primary examples of when the desire to carry multiple books is evident. Unfortunately, the size and weight of traditional books limits the flexibility for readers. The ability to be flexible and have options in life is a core pillar of minimalism and is limited by traditional books.

Purchase an Electronic Reader! Depending on your personal finances, electronic readers are a great investment for minimalists. Personally, I see ERDs as providing a more sustainable addition to a minimalist lifestyle. I believe the crucial element is deciding whether simply reading and purchasing books is your aim. If so, Amazon’s Kindle seems to offer the best combination between affordability and effectiveness. An ERD such as the iPad contains many more features than book storage and buying that’s reflected in it’s relative high cost. Also, the purchase of an iPad might add an unnecessary monthly cost if you choose their 3G service. As a minimalist, it’s of utmost importance to avoid The Debt Trap. Ultimately, each person has different comfort levels with technology and economic situations, however, if you are willing and have the money, the benefits of electronic readers outweighs traditional books in the long run.